There’s a moment in Primetime when Robert Pattinson’s Chris Hansen is in a bathroom with Merritt Wever’s producer character and suddenly launches into a bizarre, sneering child voice. (It’s the scene pictured above, actually.) It’s shocking in its abruptness but also the kind of detail that lives rent-free in your brain for the next decade or so.
For editor Daniel Garber , ACE, the challenge was making that feel organic in the world of the film, at that point already tipping into something tinged with the supernatural. Lance Oppenheim’s surreal, darkly comic take on the cultural phenomenon surrounding To Catch a Predator deals with some extremely serious material, but Garber and Oppenheim were determined not to bury it beneath solemnity.
“Lance and I are both pretty firm believers that it’s worth addressing really serious subject matter, but often doing so with a heavy dose of levity as well,” Garber says. “It just makes the difficult subject matter go down so much more easily than if you’re really dour and the whole thing can just feel so ponderous.”
The film’s faux-documentary framework was part of that thinking from the beginning. Oppenheim and Garber were interested in the ethics of turning real lives into entertainment, particularly when To Catch a Predator rarely seemed interested in the same ethical questions itself.
That made the fictional Chris Hansen less a portrait of the actual man than a portrait of the media persona he had constructed. The film’s increasingly fantastical form—including its supernatural elements—helps establish that distinction.
“It really encourages the audience to see this person as a character and not as a direct reflection on a real person,” Garber says.
That freedom also extended to Pattinson’s performance. Rather than giving Garber essentially the same Hansen from take to take, Pattinson constantly changed things up, thriving on uncertainty. For an editor, that meant an unusually rich pile of material to sculpt.
The bathroom outburst almost didn’t make it. Garber left the take out of his first cut because he wasn’t sure how to support something so extreme. Oppenheim eventually suggested bringing it back.
“We find this moment that just feels like a diamond in the rough,” Garber says, “and we have to figure out how to polish it in the right way so that it really shines in the final cut of the film.”
The same philosophy applied to the movie’s wildest sequence: the Murphy decoy house, where rain, blackouts, and a mysterious disappearing car push Primetime into horror territory. Garber initially wondered whether the sequence could work at all. The script’s “ghost car” was one thing on the page; making an audience accept it was another.
The rooftop sequence and the film’s supernatural origin story, shot in Sri Lanka during additional photography months into postproduction, helped establish a world where the impossible could gradually become plausible.
“I always believed in” the ghost car sequence, Garber says. “I just thought, this is amazing. This is unlike anything that I’ve seen.”
The final sequence underwent an equally long evolution. Originally, the movie ended with Hansen trapped in a loop, repeating the predator’s chat logs forever. It worked—but felt bleak. The filmmakers eventually returned to Dan, the audience surrogate whose journey from naïve participant to dazed witness gives the film much of its emotional weight.
That ending was shot remarkably late in the edit, after Oppenheim and actor Skyler Gisondo came up with the idea that Dan could get his SAG card. The resulting sequence leaves his fate deliberately unresolved.
Garber says there were versions where Dan answered the final question—“Are you an actor?”—but they ultimately decided silence was stronger: “The ambiguity was actually the best thing that we could leave the audience with.”
That editing philosophy runs through Primetime : Don’t explain the weirdness. That moment in a Subway with a cardboard cutout of Jared Fogle? Nobody mentions it, but viewers of a certain age will clock the dark comedy immediately. And that’s the secret to Primetime ’s particular appeal. The film keeps asking the audience how far they’ll go with it, and then dragging us along regardless of our answer.
“We really believe in the audience’s intelligence,” Garber says. “People go to the movies to feel engaged and to use their brains.” And maybe a sneering child’s voice afterward.
Loading comments…