About Us Advertise Careers Contact Us Privacy Policy Community Guidelines
Locating… 13°C English WhatsApp Alerts Email Alerts
BREAKING NEWS
Pakistan romps to eight-wicket win over Sri Lanka for its first test cricket series win in 2 years - WV News Thousands of non-academic workers in Sri Lankan universities strike over government’s refusal to meet pay demands - World Socialist Web Site Lower Respiratory Infections Impose Heavy Costs in Southern Sri Lanka - Bioengineer.org APOD: 2026 November 20 – V-G-R The Stormy Southwest Pacific Sri Lanka Raises Policy Rate to Ensure Inflation Reaches Target - Bloomberg.com Live coverage: SpaceX to launch classified payload for the U.S. Space Force Poker Dream 27 Sri Lanka Early Bird Packages Back After Four-Day Sellout - PokerNews KGS geologists return to Sri Lanka to share landslide expertise following 2025 cyclone - UKNow Sutherland ruled out of Sri Lanka tour; Knott and Learoyd called up - Cricinfo
SRI LANKA NEWS

Sri Lanka execution video ‘appears authentic’ - Channel 4

Lanka Hit News • Jan 7, 2010 · 16y ago • 3 min read
Share:

Sri Lankan officials branded as fake the video of alleged executions by Sri Lankan Armed Forces broadcast by Channel 4 News, but a UN investigation said it “appears authentic”.

Jonathan Miller’s report contains images that some viewers may find distressing.

The video was obtained by the group Journalists for Democracy in Sri Lanka and Channel 4 News broadcast it on 25 August 2009. It provoked an angry reaction, with Sri Lankan army spokesman Brigadier Udaya Nanayakkara immediately saying the footage was a fabrication designed to discredit security forces.

However, the report, commissioned by the UN’s Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial executions, Philip Alston, examined the video frame-by-frame and a group of experts said they could find no evidence that the video was a fake.

After 26 years of cold-blooded killing by both sides, the Sri Lankan Armed Forces defeated the Tamil Tigers in May 2009; the Tigers’ demise as violent and bloody as the campaign they had waged for a homeland.

With Tamil civilians caught in the crossfire, many claim targeted, there were allegations of brutal abuse by both sides.

In August 2009 Channel 4 News was sent a chilling video depicting the execution of nine bound, blindfolded men. We were told they were Tamils.

The source, a group of exiled Sri Lankan journalists, claimed it was filmed by a Sri Lankan soldier on his mobile phone last January.

The decision to broadcast the pictures caused a controversy which embroiled Channel 4 News and went as far as the UN Secretary General and the top echelons of the US government.

Sri Lanka accused Channel 4 News of deceitful journalism and malicious intent.

The Colombo government strenuously denied the authenticity of the footage, disputing the credibility of our source and demanding retraction.

“The conclusion clearly is that the video tape is authentic.” Philip Alston

Philip Alston, the UN special rapporteur on extrajudicial executions, released a report on the video in January 2010. He said he had concluded that the video is genuine and called for a war crimes investigation.

“The conclusion clearly is that the video tape is authentic,” he said. “I call for independent inquiry to be established to carry out an impartial investigation into war crimes and other grave violations of international humanitarian and human rights law allegedly committed in Sri Lanka.”

In his report, Philip Alston says that after viewing the pictures, he asked the Sri Lanka government to conduct an independent investigation. Initially, he says, they refused.

In September 2009, a government spokesman was interviewed on Channel 4 News about the UN rapporteur’s request.

“I’m sorry, but we don’t have to have so-called independent inquiries into any Tom, Dick and Harry allegation,” Professor Rajiva Wijesinha of the Sri Lankan ministry of disaster management said .

The Sri Lankan government had already announced to a roomful of foreign diplomats that they had “scientifically established beyond any doubt that this video was a fake”.

The Sri Lankan experts insisted that the footage could not possibly have been shot on a mobile phone. Their technical analysis concluded that there had been “very amateurish” video editing and crude audio dubbing.

The United Nations special rapporteur questioned the independence of the Sri Lankan experts, two of whom worked for the Sri Lankan Armed Forces. Releasing his report, he branded their conclusions “more impressionistic than scientific”. He said they were not impartial and that they had not been thorough.

The three experts the UN commissioned did raise some unexplained elements in the video.

There is the question of the date embedded in the video file which does not line up with when Channel 4 News were told it was filmed. There are also unexplained frames at the end of the footage. The pathologist also questions two unexplained body movements among the apparently dead victims.

The UN Special Rapporteur concludes that these anomalies are not enough to undermine what he calls “strong indications of authenticity”.

The Sri Lankan government disagreed. The foreign minister responded by casting doubt on the UN’s findings, telling a Colombo newspaper they were ambiguous. He accused the UN special rapporteur of playing politics, releasing his findings just before a presidential election.

Join the Conversation