The brewing civil war between Australian players past and present relating to the sandpaper scandal has been likened to a leadership spill, with holes and questions remaining on both sides of the story from Cape Town eight years ago.
Of the 11 players from the team plus others who were in the squad but not in the playing XI at Cape Town, six have addressed the brewing situation that is tearing Australian cricket apart.
Sandpapergate has exploded since Usman Khawaja’s book was released. Getty
Usman Khawaja , David Warner and Chadd Sayers are now aligned in their firm belief that the entire Test team knew about the ball-tampering plan.
On the flip-side, Pat Cummins has vehemently denied having any knowledge and labelled Khawaja’s allegations as “nonsense” in an extraordinary 70-minute press conference, while fellow fast-bowler Mitchell Starc is sticking solid.
Nathan Lyon and Josh Hazlewood haven’t spoken in the past week, but were part of a 2021 joint statement alongside Cummins and Starc that denied involvement.
Cameron Bancroft said he would offer “no comment at this stage” when asked by media last week, but has said in the past it was “self-explanatory” the bowlers knew.
Steve Smith has yet to address the claims, but will have no choice but to face the music in the coming weeks before Australia’s Test series against New Zealand.
Mitchell Marsh tiptoed around questions before the ODI series against England began, while his brother Shaun has been silent. Tim Paine hasn’t and probably can’t speak on the topic, given he is employed by CA as a Big Bash coach.
It has created an uneasy feeling throughout the game and while both sides of the ledger are strong in their recollections, we’re no closer to getting to the truth.
Speaking to Nine’s Today on Monday morning, cricket journalist Geoff Lemon - a co-host of The Final Word podcast - conceded that while the Khawaja-Warner-Sayers group had given little evidence, it was up to CA to find out and divulge the “objective truth” once and for all.
“It’s kind of like they’re doing the numbers for a leadership spill at the moment, working out who is ending up on one side,” he said.
“Tim Paine is a coach in the Big Bash. Five of the players are still currently playing in the Test team and Mitch Marsh is the one-day captain. There’s a lot of players who basically won’t speak out. It’s a matter of where the numbers are falling.
“We haven’t had any of the players who are insisting this version happened – Khawaja, Warner, Sayers – specifically say that Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon were there and involved in the conversation.
“They’ve been very general about it and said ‘we think everybody in the team knew’ but they haven’t said when these conversations were happening, these guys were privy to it. David Warner has made a lot of broad statements, but he hasn’t made any really specific statements, which is the bit that’s yet to come out.
“I think it’s just weak leadership, and it has been throughout. Everybody is talking about throwing each other under buses … but Cricket Australia are not looking after the players in their employ at the moment.
“This isn’t a matter of opinion, this is a matter of truth – there is an objective truth that could be found, and I think Cricket Australia have the responsibility to their players to try and find out what that is and let the public know.”
Khawaja, Warner and Sayers have indeed made rather sweeping statements, but the more they speak the more finer details emerge.
The main focus has been on Khawaja, who was criticised by Cummins for being “casual” with the way he spoke about his ex-teammates.
Senior cricket journalist Peter Lalor believes the spat between the two “poster boys” has become a “very damaging situation” for the sport in Australia.
“Usman has painted himself into a corner,” he told ABC’s Offsiders .
“What we saw in that 7.30 Report interview is Usman attempting to go this far, but not that far and that’s in an attempt to protect Pat Cummins and other players.
“It’s naïve to think you can protect them and that was perhaps the most telling thing that Cummins said, that he [Khawaja] had been casual with their reputations and their friendships – that was a knife in the heart, I didn’t see that coming.
“I thought Cummins would be a little more conciliatory, there was a lot of thought that he would choose a middle path … but he turned very strongly on Khawaja.
Long-time teammates Usman Khawaja and Pat Cummins pictured in 2018. Getty
“Reputationally, this is a very damaging situation. Pat Cummins is the poster boy for the Australian cricket brand these days with the big blue eyes, shiny teeth, nice hair, plays cricket in a wonderful manner – but equally, Usman Khawaja was the poster boy for the new-look Australian cricket team. The fact you could have a Pakistan-born Muslim playing cricket for Australia was so important.
“They were probably the two guys you would grab for an ad if you wanted to sell breakfast cereal, but now they’re fighting over breakfast.”
Cummins and Starc have pedalled the same line of not knowing sandpaper was “going out onto the field” but there are serious holes in their version of events.
As more people take the other side, Cummins giving a “100 per cent” rebuttal of Khawaja’s story loses credibility.
“So ... what Pat Cummins said in his presser can’t be right. He said Khawaja’s claims that everyone knew were “100 per cent nonsense” but Sayers says he knew,” English cricket journalist Barney Ronay wrote on social media.
“So clearly Cummins hadn’t asked him. So why say it’s 100 per cent if you haven’t done your due diligence on that? And what else is a guess?”
Pat Cummins press conference LIVE updates: Usman Khawaja book claims about 2018 sandpaper scandal slammed by Australian cricket captain Getty Images
There have been calls for Cricket Australia to either reopen the investigation, which chief executive Todd Greenberg has shut down, or release the original files and evidence that was given by players and staff eight years ago.
Australian great Jason Gillespie doubts that will fix the “absolute mess” they are facing, with no real winners in the ugly situation.
“We’ve heard pretty much something different from everyone,” he told BBC.
“Cricket Australia need to be the ones fronting the press and fronting the public. Whether they release the information they know – my understanding is they were confidential conversations – so where do we go from here?
“What happens if it is found out one way or the other that either no one knew or everyone knew ... what happens then? It’s an absolute mess.”
relating to the sandpaper scandal has been likened to a leadership spill, with holes and questions remaining on both sides of the story from Cape Town eight years ago.
, and are now aligned in their firm belief that the entire Test team knew about the ball-tampering plan.
On the flip-side, has vehemently denied having any knowledge and in an extraordinary 70-minute press conference, while fellow fast-bowler is sticking solid.
and haven’t spoken in the past week, but were part of a 2021 joint statement alongside Cummins and Starc that denied involvement.
said he would offer “no comment at this stage” when asked by media last week, but has said in the past it was “self-explanatory” the bowlers knew.
has yet to address the claims, but will have no choice but to face the music in the coming weeks before Australia’s Test series against New Zealand.
before the ODI series against England began, while his brother has been silent. hasn’t and probably can’t speak on the topic, given he is employed by CA as a Big Bash coach.
Senior cricket journalist believes the spat between the two “poster boys” has become a “very damaging situation” for the sport in Australia.
There have been calls for Cricket Australia to either reopen the investigation, which chief executive has shut down, or release the original files and evidence that was given by players and staff eight years ago.
Australian great doubts that will fix the “absolute mess” they are facing, with no real winners in the ugly situation.
Loading comments…